Every commercial HVAC system in California is designed twice: once on paper, and once in the field by the people who install it. Title 24 acceptance testing is the moment the state asks a simple question about the second version: does the system actually do what the first version promised? The answer is recorded, test by test, on a family of forms that start with the letters NRCA-MCH.
This guide is a field reference to those forms. It explains where acceptance testing sits in California's compliance process, walks through each mechanical acceptance test, what triggers it, what the technician actually does, and what tends to go wrong, and closes with how to prepare a building so the tests pass on the first visit. If you are new to the topic, start with our shorter introduction to Title 24 HVAC acceptance testing, then come back here. When you are ready to schedule, our Title 24 acceptance testing service covers every test described below.
Where acceptance testing fits in Title 24
California's Building Energy Efficiency Standards (Title 24, Part 6) are enforced through a chain of documents. Each link answers a different question, and acceptance testing is the last link before the building department signs off on the mechanical permit.
The compliance document families for nonresidential mechanical systems. The NRCC lists which acceptance tests the project needs; the NRCA forms are the proof.
- NRCC (Certificate of Compliance) is prepared by the designer and reviewed at plan check. For mechanical systems it identifies the equipment, the controls the code requires, and, importantly, the acceptance tests that will be needed.
- NRCI (Certificate of Installation) is signed by the installing contractor, stating the installed systems match the approved design and the code.
- NRCA (Certificate of Acceptance) is completed after field testing. Each NRCA-MCH form covers one type of test and records the measurements, the pass or fail result, and the signatures of the people responsible.
The building inspector generally will not final the mechanical permit until every required NRCA form has been completed with a passing result, and, where the jurisdiction or the current code requires it, registered with an approved data registry.
Start with the NRCC
The single most useful document for planning acceptance testing is the mechanical NRCC from plan check. It tells you which tests apply to which units. If you cannot find it, ask the designer before construction ends. Discovering a required test the week of final is the most common way acceptance testing becomes a schedule problem.
Who performs acceptance tests
Acceptance tests are performed by a field technician and signed by a responsible person, typically a licensed contractor or engineer who takes responsibility for the results. For certain mechanical tests, Title 24 and its administrative provisions require the technician to be a certified Acceptance Test Technician (ATT) working through an approved Acceptance Test Technician Certification Provider (ATTCP), with specific requirements for training, equipment, and quality assurance. Because which tests require an ATT has changed across code cycles, confirm the current requirement for your project's permit date before you choose a tester.
Independence matters in practice even where it is not required. A tester who is not the installing contractor has no reason to overlook a failure, and inspectors know it.
The mechanical acceptance tests, one by one
The form numbering below follows the recent NRCA-MCH form set. Numbers and exact scope can change between code cycles, so treat this as a map of the territory and confirm the forms listed on your project's NRCC.
| Form | Test | Typical trigger |
| NRCA-MCH-02 | Outdoor air | Systems providing required ventilation |
| NRCA-MCH-03 | Constant volume, single zone HVAC | Single zone units with constant volume fans |
| NRCA-MCH-04 | Air distribution duct leakage | Small single zone systems with ducts in unconditioned space |
| NRCA-MCH-05 | Air economizer controls | Units with required or installed air economizers |
| NRCA-MCH-06 | Demand-controlled ventilation | Densely occupied spaces requiring DCV |
| NRCA-MCH-07 | Supply fan variable flow controls | VAV systems with variable speed supply fans |
| NRCA-MCH-08 | Valve leakage | Hydronic systems with control valves |
| NRCA-MCH-09 | Supply water temperature reset | Chilled and hot water systems with reset |
| NRCA-MCH-10 | Hydronic system variable flow control | Variable flow pumping systems |
| NRCA-MCH-11 | Automatic demand shed controls | Systems with required demand response controls |
| NRCA-MCH-12 | Fault detection and diagnostics (packaged DX) | Packaged units requiring FDD |
| NRCA-MCH-13 | FDD for air handlers and zone terminal units | Built-up systems with FDD controls |
| Later forms | Energy storage, supply air temperature reset, condenser water reset, energy management control systems, ventilation occupancy controls | When those systems or controls are installed |
Outdoor air (MCH-02)
Proves the system delivers its design minimum ventilation. Outdoor airflow is measured directly or calculated from accurate temperature readings, and for VAV systems it is checked again at reduced supply flow, where outdoor air most often drops. Typical failures: minimum damper position set by eye, and VAV systems whose outdoor air falls when boxes throttle. Our ventilation acceptance article goes deeper.
Constant volume, single zone HVAC (MCH-03)
Verifies the basic control functions of single zone units: the thermostat brings on heating and cooling correctly, the fan runs continuously during occupied hours to provide ventilation (and cycles appropriately when unoccupied), setback and setup schedules work, and the unit does not heat and cool simultaneously. It sounds simple, and it is, which is why skipped thermostat programming is the usual failure.
Air distribution duct leakage (MCH-04)
Applies to smaller single zone systems where a significant share of the ductwork runs through unconditioned space such as an attic or outdoors. The duct system is pressurized and leakage measured, much like residential HERS duct testing, and compared to the code limit. Rooftop units with long exposed duct runs on small commercial buildings are the classic case.
Air economizer controls (MCH-05)
Confirms the economizer dampers stroke fully, sensors read accurately, the high-limit shutoff is the right type and setpoint for the climate zone, the economizer integrates with mechanical cooling, and relief works. See our dedicated economizer acceptance testing guide.
Demand-controlled ventilation (MCH-06)
Verifies CO2 sensors are installed and calibrated as required and that outdoor air increases when CO2 rises above setpoint and returns to the base rate when it falls, never dropping below the code minimum for the space.
Supply fan variable flow controls (MCH-07)
Tests that the supply fan speed tracks the duct static pressure setpoint, that the static pressure sensor is located and calibrated correctly, and that the setpoint is reset downward based on zone demand where the code requires it. Static pressure reset is where large VAV systems save the most fan energy, and it is often left disabled at start-up because it was "causing complaints".
Illustrative reset logic. The acceptance test confirms the fan responds to the static pressure setpoint and that the setpoint actually moves with zone demand.
Valve leakage (MCH-08)
For hydronic systems, confirms that two-way control valves shut tightly. With the valve commanded closed and the pump at shutoff head, flow through the coil should be negligible. Leaking valves keep pumps working and waste heating or cooling, and they make variable flow pumping ineffective.
Supply water temperature reset (MCH-09)
Verifies that chilled water and hot water supply temperatures reset based on outdoor temperature or load as the sequence specifies, and that the sensors used for the reset read accurately.
Hydronic system variable flow control (MCH-10)
Confirms that pumps serving variable flow systems slow down as control valves close, controlled from a properly located differential pressure sensor, rather than riding a bypass at full speed.
Automatic demand shed controls (MCH-11)
Where required, checks that the energy management system can receive a demand response signal and raise cooling setpoints (or lower heating setpoints) across zones, then return to normal when the event ends.
Fault detection and diagnostics (MCH-12 and MCH-13)
FDD controls are expected to detect and report specific faults: an economizer that does not open, a damper stuck open, a failed sensor, or, for air handlers and terminal units, conditions such as simultaneous heating and cooling. The test simulates faults and confirms the controller flags them. Equipment that "has FDD" on the submittal but was never configured is a frequent finding.
Acceptance testing does not ask whether the equipment can do the job. It asks whether this equipment, in this building, with these controls, does it.
The instruments behind a credible acceptance test
An acceptance form is only as good as the measurements behind it. The forms ask for values, not opinions, and those values come from instruments that should be calibrated and appropriate for the measurement:
- Reference thermometers and data loggers to check outdoor, return, mixed, and supply air sensors, and to log temperatures while a sequence runs through its modes.
- Digital micromanometers for duct static pressure, building pressure, and the velocity pressure readings behind airflow traverses.
- Pitot tubes, hot-wire anemometers, and capture hoods for outdoor and supply airflow, depending on what access the system allows.
- CO2 reference instruments or calibration gas for demand-controlled ventilation checks.
- Duct leakage testers for air distribution leakage on smaller systems.
- Hydronic differential pressure and flow instruments for valve leakage and variable flow tests.
- Access to the building automation system, which is effectively an instrument too: trends, overrides, and point values are how most functional tests are driven and documented.
Recording the instrument and its calibration date on the test records is a small habit that makes the results defensible if an inspector, owner, or commissioning agent asks how a number was obtained.
Acceptance testing on alterations versus new construction
On new buildings, acceptance testing usually covers every mechanical system, and the main challenge is coordination. On alterations, such as rooftop unit replacements, tenant improvements, and controls upgrades, the scope is narrower but less obvious. Only the altered systems need testing, and the NRCC for the alteration defines which tests apply. Two patterns cause most confusion:
- Like-for-like replacements that are not like-for-like in code terms. A new unit above the economizer or FDD thresholds brings those requirements, and their tests, even if the old unit had neither.
- Controls-only upgrades that change sequences affecting ventilation, economizers, or fan control. Even without new equipment, those functions may need to be verified.
Preparing a building for acceptance testing
Most failed acceptance tests are not equipment defects. They are readiness problems: controls not finished, points not mapped, systems not balanced. A building is ready when the following are true.
- Start-up is complete on every unit, with manufacturer start-up sheets available.
- Air balancing is done and the TAB report is at least in draft. Outdoor air and economizer tests verify the balanced system; testing an unbalanced one wastes a trip. See air balancing.
- Controls are programmed, not just installed. Sequences of operation are loaded, schedules set, trends available, and a controls technician can be on site or remote to override points.
- Sensors are installed in their final locations and calibrated, with calibration records.
- Access is arranged to roofs, mechanical rooms, ceiling spaces, and control panels.
- The NRCC, approved mechanical drawings, sequences, and equipment submittals are on hand for the tester.
- The NRCI forms are complete so the paperwork chain is not stalled at the installer step.
What a good acceptance testing partner does differently
- Reviews the NRCC early and gives the contractor a list of required tests and readiness items weeks before testing.
- Coordinates with the balancer and controls contractor, or performs balancing as well, so tests are not scheduled before the system is ready.
- Uses calibrated instruments and records the readings that support each pass, not just check marks.
- Reports failures with a cause, not just a result, so the responsible trade can fix it quickly.
- Completes and submits the forms in the format the jurisdiction expects.
Frequently asked questions
Are acceptance tests required on HVAC replacements in existing buildings?
Often, yes. Alterations that add or replace equipment or controls can trigger the same acceptance tests for the altered systems. The NRCC for the alteration permit lists them.
Can acceptance testing replace commissioning?
No. Acceptance tests verify specific code-required functions. Commissioning is a broader quality process that may include them. Title 24 has separate commissioning requirements for many buildings. Our article on TAB versus commissioning explains the difference.
How long does acceptance testing take?
It depends on the number of systems and tests and, above all, on readiness. A ready building with a handful of rooftop units can often be tested in a day. A building with unfinished controls can take several trips.
What happens when a test fails?
The responsible contractor corrects the problem and the test is repeated. The form is completed only with a passing result. A clear failure report shortens this loop.
Need Title 24 acceptance testing?
We review your NRCC, tell you exactly which tests apply, coordinate with your balancer and controls contractor, perform the tests with calibrated instruments, and complete the NRCA forms. Based in Sacramento, serving Northern California, with larger projects statewide.
Request a Quote
About this article. Related reading: planning acceptance testing on a commercial project and why acceptance tests fail. Form names, scope, and certification requirements are summarized from Title 24 Part 6 and its forms for education and change between code cycles; confirm current requirements for your permit with the designer and building department.