An acceptance test rarely fails because a piece of equipment is defective. It fails because a linkage was never tightened, a sensor was mounted in the sun, a sequence was loaded with factory defaults, or a setpoint was typed in the wrong units. Small things. The kind of things nobody checks until someone is standing on the roof with a calibrated instrument and a form that needs a number.
This article catalogs the failures that come up most often in Title 24 mechanical acceptance testing, grouped by test, with the cause and the fix for each. Use it as a pre-test checklist. For background on the tests themselves, see our guide to the NRCA-MCH forms; for scheduling, see planning acceptance testing on a commercial project. If you would rather have someone find these before the inspector does, that is what our Title 24 acceptance testing service is for.
Four root causes behind almost every failure
Nearly every failure below traces back to one of these four categories, and each has a simple prevention step before the tester arrives.
Outdoor air (MCH-02)
- Minimum position set by eye. The damper was set "about 20% open" at start-up. Measured outdoor air is far from design. Fix: set the minimum position, or the outdoor airflow setpoint, from measured airflow during balancing.
- Outdoor air collapses at low supply flow. On VAV systems, a fixed minimum position that is correct at full flow delivers less outdoor air as the fan slows. Fix: a control strategy that maintains outdoor airflow across the operating range, such as a measured outdoor air setpoint or a reset of minimum position with fan speed.
- Temperature method used with too small a difference. Calculating outdoor air fraction from outdoor, return, and mixed air temperatures is unreliable when those temperatures are close together. Fix: measure on a day or time with a useful temperature difference, or measure airflow directly.
- Mixed air sensor stratification. A single-point mixed air sensor reads one stream, not the mix. Fix: averaging sensor, or direct airflow measurement.
Constant volume single zone (MCH-03)
- Fan set to "auto" during occupied hours. The unit provides ventilation only when it heats or cools. Fix: program the fan to run continuously during occupied periods.
- No occupied schedule. The thermostat ships without a setback schedule and runs 24/7 at occupied settings. Fix: program occupied and unoccupied schedules and setpoints to match the building's hours.
- Deadband too small, letting the unit swing between heating and cooling. Fix: set separate heating and cooling setpoints with an adequate deadband.
Duct leakage (MCH-04)
- Unsealed curb or plenum connections on rooftop units. Fix: seal the unit-to-curb and plenum joints with appropriate materials before testing.
- Leaky return in the attic, built from framing or with open corners at the filter grille. Fix: seal the return box and boots; treat it like residential duct sealing.
- Test set up against an open economizer or open outdoor air path, so the "leakage" includes the outdoor air opening. Fix: seal intentional openings per the test procedure before pressurizing.
Economizer (MCH-05)
- Actuator moves, damper does not. A loose or never-connected linkage. Fix: stroke each damper and watch the blades, not the actuator.
- Shipping bracket or screw still installed. Fix: remove all shipping restraints at start-up.
- Outdoor air sensor reading high because it sits in direct sun or near the unit's own condenser discharge. Fix: relocate and shield it; verify against a reference thermometer.
- High-limit setpoint left at factory default rather than the value the code allows for the building's climate zone and control type. Fix: set it from the code table and record it.
- Economizer locked out when compressors run, so it never provides integrated cooling. Fix: enable integrated operation in the unit or building controls.
- No relief. With outdoor air at 100%, the building over-pressurizes; doors whistle and the economizer underperforms. Fix: confirm barometric or powered relief is installed and operating.
Illustrative values. A sensor that reads a few degrees high can disable economizing on exactly the mild days when it saves the most energy.
Demand-controlled ventilation (MCH-06)
- CO2 sensor in the return duct where the code calls for a sensor in the space. Fix: install it in the breathing zone of the space it serves.
- Setpoint entered as an absolute value without accounting for outdoor CO2 as required. Fix: configure the setpoint per the code's method.
- DCV closes outdoor air completely when the room is empty. Fix: maintain the base ventilation rate the code requires during occupied hours.
- The signal never reaches the unit. The sensor reads correctly at the wall, but the economizer controller never receives it. Fix: point-to-point checkout of the CO2 signal path.
Supply fan variable flow (MCH-07)
- Static pressure sensor at the fan discharge instead of out in the duct system where the code and sequence expect it. Fix: relocate to a representative point, typically two-thirds of the way down the main duct or as the design specifies.
- Static pressure reset disabled after start-up complaints. Fix: correct the underlying zone problem (often a bad VAV flow coefficient) rather than disabling the reset. See our VAV balancing article.
- Drive in hand mode at a fixed speed. Fix: return the VFD to automatic control from the building controls.
Hydronic tests (MCH-08, MCH-09, MCH-10)
- Control valves leak through because they are not rated for the system's shutoff pressure, or actuators do not fully close them. Fix: confirm close-off ratings and actuator stroke.
- Three-way valves or open bypasses defeat variable flow. Fix: follow the design: two-way valves where variable flow is required, and limited bypass sized for minimum pump flow.
- Differential pressure sensor at the pump, not at the hydraulically remote coil. Fix: locate it per the design so the pump can actually slow down.
- Supply water temperature reset not programmed or locked to a fixed setpoint. Fix: program the reset schedule in the sequence and verify the sensors used for it.
Fault detection and diagnostics (MCH-12, MCH-13)
- FDD hardware present but not configured. The controller can detect faults, but nobody enabled the function or set the alarm destinations. Fix: configure FDD at start-up and confirm alarms reach a person or system.
- Unit substituted without FDD capability. Fix: check equipment submittals against the compliance documents before ordering.
- Faults detected but not displayed. The FDD module flags the fault on an internal code that no one sees. Fix: make sure faults are reported where the code requires them to be visible.
Thirty failures, and not one of them requires new equipment. They require someone to look before the tester does.
A pre-test walk that catches most of these
Two hours with the mechanical foreman and the controls technician, a week before testing, will catch the majority of the items above. Walk each unit with this list:
- Shipping restraints removed; dampers stroke fully and blades follow the actuator.
- Outdoor air, mixed air, supply air, and return sensors installed in final locations and spot-checked against a reference.
- Economizer high-limit type and setpoint match the code table for the climate zone.
- Minimum outdoor air set from measured airflow (balancing report in hand).
- Fan runs continuously in occupied mode; schedules programmed.
- CO2 sensors in the space, signal reaching the unit controller, setpoints configured per code.
- Static pressure sensor location and reset logic verified; VFDs in auto.
- FDD enabled, alarms routed, and a test fault displayed.
- Hydronic valves close off; differential pressure sensors at the correct location.
- NRCC, sequences, submittals, and NRCI forms available on site.
Three short case patterns
The following are composite patterns, not specific projects, but anyone who tests buildings regularly will recognize them.
The economizer that tested itself into failure
A retail building's rooftop units pass start-up, and the controls contractor reports that the economizers "work". During acceptance testing, the outdoor air sensor on two units reads several degrees higher than the reference thermometer. The sensors were mounted on the sunny side of the unit, just above the condenser coil. At the code's high-limit setpoint, the economizers would lock out on most of the mild mornings they were meant to use. Relocating and shielding the sensors fixes the problem in an hour; finding it took a reference instrument and a few minutes of comparison.
The VAV system that passed at full flow
An office building's air handler delivers its design outdoor air at full supply flow, and the outdoor air test passes at that condition. At reduced supply flow, with most boxes near minimum, measured outdoor air drops well below design. The minimum outdoor air damper position was fixed. The solution is a controls change that maintains outdoor airflow as the fan slows, followed by a retest at the reduced flow condition, which is exactly why the procedure checks both.
The FDD that never told anyone
A packaged unit with built-in fault detection is substituted for the specified model late in the project. It does have FDD capability, but the function is disabled by default and faults display only on the unit's local board. During testing, a simulated damper fault produces no visible alarm. Configuring the function and routing alarms takes less time than the retest that follows, and far less than discovering the problem after occupancy.
What a failed test actually costs
The direct cost of a retest is the smallest part. The real cost is time: a re-mobilization for the tester, a return trip for the controls technician, and, if testing was scheduled the week of final, a delayed inspection that can push back occupancy. On tenant improvements, that delay can mean rent paid on space that cannot be used. Planning a readiness gate and a pre-test walk costs a fraction of one retest.
Frequently asked questions
Can a contractor run the tests informally before the official test?
Yes, and it is a good idea. A pre-test by the installing contractor using the same procedures catches most problems. The official test and the NRCA forms are then completed by the responsible tester.
If one test fails, do all tests on the unit have to be repeated?
Generally only the failed test is repeated after correction, unless the fix changes something other tests depend on, such as a sensor or minimum position. A good tester will tell you which.
Do inspectors check the measured values or just the pass box?
Practices vary, but complete forms with measured values and instrument information are far easier to defend if a question comes up, and some jurisdictions review them closely.
Want your acceptance tests to pass the first time?
We can do a pre-test walk with your team, then perform the official acceptance tests and complete the NRCA forms, coordinated with air balancing. Sacramento and Northern California.
Request a Quote
About this article. Related reading: economizer acceptance testing and outdoor air and DCV tests. Failure descriptions are general field observations for education; procedures and acceptance criteria are defined by the current Title 24 Part 6 forms for your project.